Divorce Blog

Who Gets the Pet? Pet Custody in a New York Divorce

By Ellis A. Lockhart

In New York State, as of October 25, 2021, courts are required to consider the “best interest” of a companion animal when awarding possession of that companion animal. This applies to pets that were acquired during the marriage. If one spouse owed the pet prior to the marriage, it is likely that the pet is that spouse’s separate property and will remain with them.

With this change in the law, if you and your spouse are unable to come to an agreement regarding who will be keeping your pets after a divorce, the court can hold a hearing to determine who will keep the pet. The hearing can include testimony from you, your spouse, and paperwork related to the pet. Every hearing is different depending on the parties and their specific circumstances.

When the court is the one making the determination of the best interest of the companion animal, the court will consider several factors to determine which spouse should have possession over the companion animal. These include who takes care of the pet on a daily basis; who takes the pet to the veterinarian; who is able to financially support the pet; the home environment of each spouse; whether either party has committed acts of domestic violence; and the care and affection shown to the pet.

In New York, while a court can set a visitation schedule between the parties for the pet, this is unlikely. The current view in New York is that it is in the best interest of the pet to remain with one party as a visitation schedule opens the possibility of future litigation about the visitation schedule. While pets are now seen as more than a piece of property, the court still distinguishes their treatment from that of a child.

This does not prevent you and your spouse from coming to a settlement agreement regarding your pet. Coming to an agreement gives you more flexibility than a court may award.
Notwithstanding the above, the court always has the discretion to deviate from the statutory formulas and tailor-make a solution for the parents. Your rights and obligations should be discussed with experienced counsel to ensure the best result for you, and your children. The matrimonial and family law attorneys at O’Connell & Aronowitz are ready to assist you. Contact us at 518-462-5601 or fill out a form on our website.

Back to Top